BritBox VS. Acorn TV: Which One Is A Better Streaming Service?

BritBox VS. Acorn TV: Which One Is A Better Streaming Service?

At the first glance, Acorn TV and BritBox seem basically the same: The both offer a mix of old school and new crime series from Poirot to Vera along with a host of documentaries and popular British films. They are both available on platforms like Amazon Video and even their subscription price point is in the same range.

So when it comes to watching British TV via streaming services, does it matter picking one vs. the other? Actually it does. These two streaming services, although have some similarities, are quite different in terms of focus and breadth of offerings they bring to their audience.

We have done a side-by-side comparison of these two services from various angles to help you choose what fits your needs:

History of BritBox vs. Acorn TV

Acorn TV has had a presence in the U.S. market for more than two decades. Acorn Media Group has distributed British television in the United States since 1994, originally selling VHS tapes via catalogues before moving into DVD and Blu-ray media.

Continuing the company’s expansion into new formats, the company launched a direct-to-consumer e-commerce website in 2011 and in 2013, Acorn TV was relaunched as a standalone service with expanded content offerings and monthly and annual subscription options.

Trying to create a niche for itself, the company has been offering exclusive content, starting with the US premiere of Doc Martin, Series 6. In 2015, Acorn TV was the only niche streaming service to have a program nominated for an Emmy when Curtain: Poirot’s Last Case was nominated for Best Television Movie. As of December 31, 2016, it had 430,000 paid subscribers. The company’s shows have also been nominated for Edgar Awards, the prestigious prize offered by Mystery Writers of America (MWA).

Currently Acorn TV subscription streaming service offering television programming from the United Kingdom, as well as Ireland, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand. It is available on a variety of devices including Amazon Fire TV, Apple TV, and Roku.

BritBox, on the other hand, is much more newer service. As a video on-demand service owned by BBC Studios and ITV plc., the company has certainly the financial backing and access to material necessary to penetrate British TV market niche.

So far, BritBox has focused on British television series, featuring current and past series supplied from the BBC and ITV. Some series, such as Coronation Street, have new episodes available within a day after their British premiere, although generally within just a few hours of its UK airing.

The streaming service’s launch was officially announced in March 2017. It reported a subscriber base of 250,000 in one year, as of March 2018. So although it is still smaller than Acorn TV in size, it is growing faster and is already becoming a serious rival.

BritBox’s service area includes the U.S. and Canada. However, the programs available in each country are not identical. For example, BritBox carries Coronation Street in the U.S. but not in Canada, where the corresponding rights have long been held by CBC Television.

The Differences Between BritBox vs. Acorn TV

The most visible difference between the two services is price: At $4.99 a month, Acorn TV is 29% cheaper than BritBox which charges customers $6.99 per a single month of subscription. With an annual plan, both streaming services charge the equivalent of 10 months for 12 months of access to their portfolio of films and TV series.

Acorn TV, on the other hand, has an impressive list of Original series

While both services have similar offerings in terms of classic mystery shows such as Hercule Poirot or Agatha Christie’s Ms. Marple, BritBox has a much larger and higher growing inventory of new shows, thanks to generous support of BBC and ITV.

Acorn TV, on the other hand, has an impressive list of Original series with some already having a loyal follower base. The haunting shore of Scotland’s most iconic loch is, for example, the stunning backdrop for Acorn TV Original mystery series Loch Ness that follows the search for a serial killer.

Other shows from Acorn TV’s impressive stable of original programming include The Detectorists, Keeping Faith, and the Emmy-nominated Curtain: Poirot’s Last Stand.

BritBox does not have as many notable Non-British films and shows. Its portfolio however is younger and sexier. There are more up-to-date lifestyle shows and LGBTQ titles like Tipping the Velvet and Christopher and His Kind.

So Should I Subscribe To BritBox Or Acorn TV?

It depends on what your are looking for. Acorn TV seems to be more solid in terms of its list of old-school mystery TV series and shows. It also has a growing list of original series with amazing plots (Loch Ness is a case in point). For fresh content and shows which are currently running on BBC or ITV or were recently aired, BritBox is the place to go.

If money is not a problem, we recommend you to subscribe to both to enjoy the best of both worlds.

    1. I just signed up for a trial month of Acorn, and they say they will bill me at $5.99!
      I don’t know if the price has gone up since this article was written, or if they’re charging more because of the “free” trial.
      From all my research, it had looked like Acorn was right for me, but I see little content I want. Nevertheless, a few shows will keep me happy for the duration.
      Next, I’ll go to BritBox and see how that fares!

      1. Month to month plan cost is 5.99$. If you pay up front for one year (59.99$) the total comes out to 4.99$/month (59.99$/ 12 = 4.99/month)

      2. Mar, my favorite Acorn show so far: Murdoch, poirot collection, Delicious, Midsomer, Loch Ness, Vera, Detectorists, Miss Fisher, George Gently, Hamish Macbeth, Foyle’s war.

          1. I have seen them mostly on PBS over the years. I have had both Acorn and Britbox for over a year and it seems like they both never change much at all. I love British mysteries and movies but am getting tired of not much new. Getting ready to spend money on other streaming services.

    2. Up until a couple months ago, the official line was that the actress playing Miss Fisher wanted to move on to different things. However, I just noticed that there is a new series available from either Acorn or Britbox that has a new series coming up this year. I don’t know if it’s the same actress or not.

      1. The show is called Ms Fisher’s Modern Murder Mysteries and it follows Phyrne Fisher’s niece, Peregrine Fisher (played by Geraldine Hakewill), in the 1960s. UNfortunately, it is nowhere as good as the original.

    3. Today the current show is called Ms Fisher’s Modern Murder Mysteries and it follows Phyrne Fisher’s niece, Peregrine Fisher (played by Geraldine Hakewill), in the 1960s. Luckily ACORN TV has the three seasons produced of the original Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries with Essie Davis. It’s an Australian show so it’s on ACORN. Normally Brit Box only has British Shows hence the name. ACORN also has another very good Aussie series Brokenwood Mysteries. Well worth the watch.

    4. I just got an email from ACORN TV announcing the release of the new feature film “Miss Fisher and the Crypt of Tears. It will be showing in select theaters starting March 13, and be streanming on ACORN TV starting March 23rd.

        1. Miss Fisher is an Australian series, the movie that was just made was run in select theaters and now is on ACORN TV.

        2. Black Work is a three part mini-series….A policewoman sets out to discover who murdered her husband, an undercover officer.

  1. Britbox, owned by the BBC and ITV, is sucking up exclusive access to top shows like Vera, Shetland and now Father Brown, stuff we used to get free on PBS or found as part of our subscription to Acorn and Netflix. The giant global monsters continue to devour everything in their path…

  2. Luv Acorn TV because luv variety of countries Canada,Australia,UK,etc luv watching mysteries other than US,example ,London Kills,Midsomer Murders.Mystery Road,etc I am hooked,lol.And Comcast does not offer Britbox,but Acorn appeals to me better.Except Vera,s new episodes were not on Acorn,but on Britbox,thats no good.

  3. I watched the new series release of Father Brown … can see the writers are adding the LGBT propaganda .. so disappointing.. So many new shows seem to think they have to push that agenda.. I, for one, do not see the need in our old favorites.

    1. @Suzy Hayden This is about comparing types of content and shows, not about specific content streamed which opposes your religious views. No one cares.

        1. Nothing religious about it, but the behavior of a minority, should be limited proportionally to the actual population. It as become fashionable in ensemble cast programming to have a gay member and in drama to center the thematic material to include at least a portion of the drama on “coming out” I find the writing tedious and repetitive and n massive amounts repugnant.

          1. And to “Frederick von Hardenberg”, who finds the writing on shows that contain what he deems to be “token gay characters with storylines that can include at least a portion of the drama on “coming out”, and who find[s] the writing “tedious and repetitive and… repugnant“:

            Do you suppose that perhaps those gay members of society
            you find so offensive (if and when you detect that they are *over-represented* on television, of course) have found it equally as tedious and repetitive, and perhaps even — what?! Yes, — “repugnant” to have been forced [“forced” being a relative term, but “forced” as YOU have been “forced” to watch these oh-so-offensive programs that you have chosen to watch, despite content you may not have particularly chosen or loved in its particulars] to watch, consisting of years and years of Old Favorite programming that offered only the most conventional (read “acceptable”) middle-of–the-road, exclusively heterosexual romances and relationships between people with equally exclusively straight families — featured in the throes of their terrible struggles over love and money, crime and punishment, life and death — all of this agony and ecstasy occurring while they are yet free to love or struggle with or over any opposite-sex person they wished — prancing about for viewers, white-washed like endlessly multiplied identical pickets in a fence,
            devoid of
            to whom
            could look
            for Inspiration
            or Courage
            when they were silenced and stuffed into their lonely, empty, enforced closets of fear and sometimes shame as well, depending on their particular circumstances?

            Well, DO you? DO you suppose that?
            Have you never tried to imagine how it must have felt to be on the other side of all this happy jollity, these noble struggles because you were not allowed to be happy for the same reasons, not allowed to struggle for the same ends?
            Perhaps if you did, you might understand why it is not unfair or impolite to invite you (or *allow* you) a glimpse into their struggles as part of many programs, whether stand-alone or series. There will come a time, probably in the not-too-distant future, when this will no longer be the case. We will have become used to this, we will expect it, we will have become inured to the shock and ire that used to accompany an appearance of *those* people in our favorite television show. Just as we are now accustomed to seeing Black and Asian characters (although Middle Eastern and other regional personalities have gone into decline again) on our screens, and sometimes not even as Example, Token or Teaching characters, sometimes treated as legitimate persons, sometimes without even a reference or nod to their non -white skin).

            Hopefully all of these distinctions will not be made in our streaming dramas. People will simply be people, loving anyone, anywhere without regard to the love they give or the person that inspires their love.

            Until then, work towards future peace by trying to step into another human being’s shoes when you feel challenged.
            Otherwise, keep your ignorant comments and your keyboard-caressing hands to yourself.

        2. Maybe they’re not ✌religious✌views, but that IS a nicer assumption than to just say “bigoted” or “homophobic”, yes? Sure, people have the right to like whatever shows they prefer, but if they say that they generally like a show, and then complain that it is being polluted by lgbtq “propaganda”, that’s a little more telling, isn’t it? If a story contains plot threads that involve regular people in society and it happens to reflect reality by depicting or making reference to their gender or sexual identity, that’s not “propaganda”, that’s simply a story being set in our world as it is today. It was “our old favorites” that were relatively dishonest. You could argue that they accurately showed a whitewashed world where homosexuality and gender dysmorphia were hidden and therefore relatively “invisible”, but that’s not quite the truth, is it? More commonly, people who were “different” were still visible, and they were not ignored as Suzy Hayden implies, but reviled, outcast, marginalized or punished for being who they were, even if they did try to hide it (for their own safety, but apparently also for the benefit of people like our Suzy, who found them…”disappointing”?). Also, the casts of those old favorites were probably filled with a much higher percentage of those otherwise shunned people (that’s probably *loud whisper*: “THE GAYS” to *you*, Suze, old dear) than non-thespian society, because the theater has historically been much more accepting of — even embracing — lgbtq people than the general public, understanding that talent and genius often come out when people are allowed to (or are determined to) show their true colors and fly freely instead of being emotionally, psychologically, even *physically* crippled, hobbled and constrained and relegated to shrink away, desperately trying to hide their true selves and using their innate (god-given?) talents and energies to devise ever-evolving (by necessity) methods to survive, to subjugate, to hide their thoughts, feelings, longings, expressions and their very souls for fear of offending someone like Miss Suzy, who would like her world view to reflect back only her fantasy of life as it might be if she were simply allowed to destroy everyone she did not like to see so that her Old Favorite television might accurately depict reality.

          So, Vivian, maybe she “said nothing about religious views”, and yes, she does have “a right to like or dislike whatever program” she wishes, but let’s call it what it is, shall we? It’s the euphemisms and suggestions and refusal to be frank that have injured (and humiliated, and terrified, and marginalized, and destroyed) a great many people who have made the world we’ve been allowed to view a thousand times more beautiful, innovative, thrilling, poignant, brilliant and COLORFUL than it would have been if they had not been there, behind the scenes, working to show us everything they held inside while forced to pretend that their lives were just as drab and empty and colorless as those of the “religious” people in our society who held them in contempt and virtual — or literal —imprisonment simply for a judgement about their very own desperate and luminous love.

    2. Pushing the agenda of not being a hateful twat? Are you going to start complaining about people of color on midsommer murders next? Stop pushing your opinion based agendas.

      1. I enjoy Acorn Tv and all actors,no matter who they are and there will be some people who do not like some of these programs,i would ignore and enjoy what you like.One thing for sure whether its Acorn Tv or BritBox,producers are not going to cut out actors cause somebody ain’t happy.

      2. Stop using foul language please, it is as offensive as the bias some people have and ruins you credibility as a rational person. I would have taken your argument much more seriously if there hadn’t been one single word that focused my thoughts away from what could have been an argument in which you could have had made a difference. Such a wasted opportunity.

      3. Why is it wrong to not like homosexuality in a show but okay to hate someone enough to call them a twat? You are an example of the very attitude you claim to stand against.

  4. I love BritBox. But, I also like Doc Martin which is on Acorn. I love Holby City and its companion medical show, Emmerdale, Monty Don, flower and travel shows. Yes. An African American that loves most things British. I lived there 1982-1986 – mmmmm.

    1. I am African American ,i have Acorn TV which i love watching programs across the pond,downunder, Canadian ,etc .Alot of actors act in Game of Thrones,Outlander,etc .I binge watch alot of Acorn Tv programs,can’t get enough,lol

  5. I subscribe to both, but find myself watching more of ACORN TV because of it’s offerings from all over the world. It’s too bad the BBC decided to start a competing service, that idea was bad for customers. One good service would be better, than dividing viewership in half.

    1. I luv Acorn Tv,would like to see more episodes of Midsomer Mysteries,My Life is Murder,Brokenwood Mysteries,Vera,London Kills,No Offence,Jack Taylor,Jack Irish these are the programs that i like and have watch all of the episodes,There are other police programs i have finished ,running low.

  6. Britbox has younger and sexier? Why not just watch US TV where no one is above late 30s, no grey hair, etc, etc, etc. seriously Ad driven TV doesn’t really give you a real cross section of humanity, or the best TV. You get the Tom Selleck black shoe polish people…..

  7. I prefer Acorn. Maybe I’m old school, but BritBox isn’t giving me the wide variety of international mysteries and dramas that Acorn does. Now that I’m fully functional with reading subtitles, it’s the variety of Acorn that keeps me paying for an annual subscription. I will occasionally pay for a month on BritBox when they have something I really like. Shakespeare and Hathaway are one example. Soon, I’ll be paying just to see the new season and whatever else they come up with, like Death in Paradise.

    1. Shakespeare and Hathaway and Death in Paradise both play on PBS for free. Unless, that is, there has been a very recent change.

  8. I was dismayed last night when Acorn interrupted my viewing of a Midsomer Murder episodes with ads EVERY 15 MINUTES! When did that start? We actually pay for Acorn, assuming there will be no ads. Is there an ad-free subscription and a cheaper “with ads” price?

  9. Took out a Trial Subscription to Acorn which we loved with the exception of all the download interruptions. There is apparently an issue with Acorn and Britbox that deals with download speeds. Our feed is the maximum, so we’re puzzled!? Any solutions or suggestions?

    1. I would start by downloading an app like ookla and checking your ACTUAL download speeds. I suspect there was buffering caused by disruptions from your cable provider.

  10. Three months after canceling this service, (they require you to insure they did it after receiving and confirming your email to cancel), they are again charging my bank account for the service I don’t have. This is after they confirmed they canceled my account three months ago. Unless they offer you an option like Paypal don’t give them your bank account info or you will be sorry. Then again just don’t get IT since I cancelled it because except for a handful of exceptions everything is just very old repeats.

  11. Brokenwood Mysteries is an interesting small town series from New Zealand. As I write this only two episodes of Series 6 have been streamed thus far on ACORN-TV , “The Power of Steam” and “A Real Page Turner.” So far the current season is better than anything in the past. The stories show better production value in the set design and quality background music apparently written for the series rather than early seasons use of “fake” country music.

  12. Brenda Blethyn returns as Vera for it’s tenth series, and the shows which have been streamed so far on BritBox hold up the same high standard as previous series. It’s good to see Paul Kaye back as pathologist Dr. Malcolm Donahue. He has some of the best dialogue on the show, as he gives it back to Vera the same way she can dash it out. Fine character played by a really good actor, hope he’s around for years to come. Great chemistry!

  13. I subscribe to Acorn TV on cable and enjoy it enormously. Doc Martin, Murdoch, Midsomer and Miss Fisher are quite worth the fees.

    1. Also, I forgot to add this: one of the BEST series I’ve ever seen (started watching on PBS) is the Australian drama “A Place to Call Home” — incredible and engaging. I don’t know if you can watch anywhere else, but I know Acorn has it and that’s why I originally subscribed to Acorn TV.

      It also has Crownies & Janet King (featuring the star of A Place to Call Home, the amazingly talented actor/ress, Marta Dusseldorp).

      Great series, I love lots of the Aussie as well as Brit series, especially the mysteries, related types. So if that helps you make a decision or gives you more to research, there ya go.

  14. Take a gander at the Brokenwood series. So wonderful. Fun mysteries and the all the beauty of New Zealand.

  15. If I’m not wrong, several of the Vera series on AcornTV were shown without closed captions [subtitles]. As an older American watcher, this makes it almost impossible to watch. Does BritBox have those episodes with cc?

  16. Which service is best for people that aren’t avid fans of serial killer sagas and police procedurals? I did like to watch the American program Dragnet now and then, when they focused on such subjects as the sale of fake watches.

  17. What exactly is it that you people find so offensive about gay characters? Suzy Hayden spoke of supposed “LGBT propaganda.” While Birgit Jones said: “This push of agenda is getting tiresome.” What propaganda and agenda are you referring to, exactly? The propaganda/agenda for gay people to be viewed as…I don’t know…just people? Just regular human beings who have families, jobs, relationships, joy, sadness, etc. just like anyone else. I happen to be a gay, Black woman, and in my 45 years on this planet I have not been able to understand what is it about my mere existence that bothers some people so much. Be it the gay part or the Black part (and for some lovely people, I’m the perfect combination of two things that they loathe), some of you are just beside yourself with the fact that people like me not only exist, but have the audacity to walk around acting as if we’re worthy of being treated like normal human beings. You see more gay people on TV and in movies these days because we exist!! We have always existed from the beginning of time. The fact that society tried to ignore that fact for centuries and tried to make us hide who we are, doesn’t make it any less true. So what you’re seeing is not an agenda. It’s simply the truth. It’s life. Gay people are all around you, no matter how “tiresome” the acknowledgement of our existence makes you. And we aren’t going anywhere. Before anyone tells me to “be kind” like you told the previous poster, trust me, this is the extremely tame version of what I wanted to say. How can you tell us to “be kind,” but say nothing to the people who voice how tired they are of the fact that people like me are no longer treated like disgusting outcasts who need to be hidden away from decent people? Kindness works both ways.

  18. Does Acorn work like Netflix with unlimited access to its programs or is an on-demand service with the programming only available for 30 days as it is on DISH?

  19. I have NetFlix, Acorn, BritBox AND Amazon Prime. I being charged Monthly for all of them It is so easy to subscribe, and almost impossible to unsubscribe. I knnow I dont need all these. Please help me.

  20. I agree wholeheartedly about APTCH, and also the female lead, excellent in every things I’ve seen her in….

  21. That’s funny I have them all.. However if you are on a budget I suggest you keep ACORN and Amazon Prime. My problem with Netflix (though it does have some good movies, they keep adding mostly their own movies and TV series. It’s cheaper than paying royalties. When I search Netflix normally I don’t get the movie I want but rather a list of films “like” the one I want. BritBox has lots of good shows but they are all English and stuff you see on PBS stations. ACORN has interesting series from all over the world, and generally stuff I have not seen. Well that’s two cents…

  22. @Pamela Donaldson, if you subscribe all these services thru Prime,
    Go to Manage Your Prime Video Channels.
    Under Prime Video Channels, find the subscription you want to cancel.
    Select Cancel Channel and confirm.

    If subscribe separately, then log in to each Account and cancel.

  23. Shakespeare and Hathaway and Death in Paradise are not shown on all PBS stations. They have not been shown on our PBS as of yet. We have had Midsummer Murders and Endeavour and Doc Martin.

  24. Paul, I know that they have a whole variety. I got my subscription from DISH On Demand and when I watch a show, I have only 30 days to watch it. Then it is no longer available to me. Is a regular subscription different from that? Is it more like Netflix where I can watch a show as many times as I want.

  25. I have Acorn Tv,the only thing some of the police series,etc. they are not talking English and its hard trying to look at close caption showing what they are saying in English.I do not care to watch series hard to to enjoy viewing,otherwise i like Acorn Tv,

  26. It’s not in proportion, and seems that ALL Shows are most likely obligated to have some form or other of same sex “sex” I admit to some legitimate logical, to me, phobias/fears , such as fearing a very detrimental effect as we, so rapidly push the envelope further away from traditional values. The push is , as we have seen in California, toward legitimacy for sex with children is legal.
    LBQTP ETC IS TO BE FESRED, CONTINUES TO go beyond reasonable decency.
    Last point, I have no problem with love….love whoever you like; but we are obviously designed and equipped for one version of love that includes sex.

  27. Love love love A Place To Call Home!!! Murdoch Murders was another favorite. But I see on internet search that Murdoch newer seasons/episodes are on Ovation now and not Acorn. Very disappointed#

  28. Watch much Acorn. Greatly enjoy. Originally was looking for BritBox but can not access BritBox with Amazon Firestick. Happy with choice of Acorn.

  29. I am happily annually subscribed to both Acorn TV and BritBox … I started on a monthly subscription with Acorn TV then after a couple of months changed to annual subs and then signed up annually for BritBox … We watch both channels every day and have been able to catch up on many shows that we have missed out on in the past …

  30. There are far more people that are gay or bi than you know. It’s not like they wear a sign or announce it upon meeting you. There’s room for everyone at the table.

  31. I like how there are streaming services that are up-to-date and have LGBTQ titles. I think it is important to always include these shows. That will help people become more acquainted with that community.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Log In

Enter username or email